From cedfacc40848dca5211b340b3ecb60a6eda4527c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Saravana Achu Mac Date: Sat, 4 Apr 2026 16:48:33 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] docs(ecosystem): close hardening tracker gaps --- .../ECOSYSTEM_IMPLEMENTATION_TRACKER.md | 67 ++++++++----------- 1 file changed, 29 insertions(+), 38 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/ecosystem/ECOSYSTEM_IMPLEMENTATION_TRACKER.md b/docs/ecosystem/ECOSYSTEM_IMPLEMENTATION_TRACKER.md index 60a4a072..72f9f7dc 100644 --- a/docs/ecosystem/ECOSYSTEM_IMPLEMENTATION_TRACKER.md +++ b/docs/ecosystem/ECOSYSTEM_IMPLEMENTATION_TRACKER.md @@ -41,16 +41,6 @@ Build a shared ByteLyst ecosystem layer so products do not behave like isolated ### What Remains In The Roadmap -- finish broader ecosystem-document maturity: - - expand adoption docs beyond the currently covered products and flows - - harden the verification matrix with repo-level test ownership - - revise the temporary ownership model if the working team changes -- finish broader spec maturity: - - shared artifact storage/lifecycle rules - - broader event taxonomy beyond the implemented phase seams - - approvals/trust policy hardening - - marketplace inventory and entitlement details - - timeline hosting/filtering decisions beyond the current baseline - optional product expansion, not baseline blockers: - richer FlowMonk replay execution controls if they prove useful - richer Cowork checkpoint drill-in if product usage justifies it @@ -58,52 +48,53 @@ Build a shared ByteLyst ecosystem layer so products do not behave like isolated ### Current Roadmap Call - the implementation roadmap baseline is materially complete through Phase 5 -- the remaining work is mostly documentation hardening and optional product expansion, not missing core baseline functionality +- the requested documentation hardening pass is complete +- the remaining work is optional product expansion, not missing core baseline functionality ### Remaining Work Buckets #### Must-Finish Hardening -- [ ] expand adoption docs beyond the currently covered products and flows +- [x] expand adoption docs beyond the currently covered products and flows Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - add missing adoption coverage for additional ecosystem repos that are expected to consume shared contracts -- [ ] harden the verification matrix with repo-level test ownership + - adoption coverage now includes SmartAuth, Auth App, mac-tooling, and JarvisJr in addition to the flow-driving repos +- [x] harden the verification matrix with repo-level test ownership Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - define who owns runtime, artifact, timeline, and e2e verification in each participating repo -- [ ] revise the temporary ownership model if the working team changes + - repo-level evidence owners and baseline command expectations are now documented +- [x] revise the temporary ownership model if the working team changes Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - current model assumes Saravana, Codex, Windsurf, and Cursor only -- [ ] define broader shared artifact storage and lifecycle rules + - revision triggers and next-state ownership shape are now documented while preserving the current four-party model +- [x] define broader shared artifact storage and lifecycle rules Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - current contract covers artifact shape, but not long-term retention, versioning, or archival rules -- [ ] broaden the shared event taxonomy beyond the currently implemented phase seams + - storage class, retention, archival, migration, and binary attachment rules are now documented +- [x] broaden the shared event taxonomy beyond the currently implemented phase seams Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - current event taxonomy is strong for Phases 1 to 5 but not yet ecosystem-complete -- [ ] harden approvals and trust policy details + - additional canonical event families now cover marketplace, identity, delivery, sync, and timeline review domains +- [x] harden approvals and trust policy details Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - current approvals/trust model is still a draft and needs a more complete policy matrix -- [ ] finish marketplace inventory and entitlement details + - approval reuse, fresh-approval classes, degraded-device handling, and approval payload requirements are now documented +- [x] finish marketplace inventory and entitlement details Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - the marketplace unification doc exists, but product inventory and entitlement rules are still open -- [ ] finish longer-term timeline hosting and filtering decisions + - canonical listing schema, entitlement guidance, compatibility, and inventory mapping are now documented +- [x] finish longer-term timeline hosting and filtering decisions Owner: - `learning_ai_common_plat` Notes: - - the current hosted timeline baseline works, but longer-term production hosting and filtering policy still needs closure + - timeline noise filtering and the current hosting choice are now documented explicitly #### Optional Product Enhancements @@ -156,15 +147,15 @@ Example: | Spec | Status | Owner Repo | Notes | Commits | | ---------------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | `ECOSYSTEM_CROSS_POLLINATION_OPPORTUNITIES.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | strategy baseline created and strengthened | `d28e9d0`, `341cde7`, `3e572b6` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_SHARED_ARTIFACT_SCHEMA.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | Phase 1 artifact schema and fixtures now exist in `@bytelyst/events`; broader storage rules still open | `eae3409`, `76f1b47` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_SHARED_ARTIFACT_SCHEMA.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | canonical artifact shape, lifecycle rules, migration guidance, and binary attachment handling are now documented | `eae3409`, `76f1b47`, `617d970` | | `ECOSYSTEM_AGENT_RUNTIME_CONTRACT.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | lifecycle boundaries, queued runs, checkpoint/resume semantics, replay requirements, and direct Cowork/FlowMonk mappings now exist | `eae3409`, `ff8c5eb`, `97b731e`, `faf93ec`, `2ad979c`, `4bb8efe`, `3330ca5` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_APPROVALS_AND_TRUST_MODEL.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | draft stub exists, policy matrix still needs hardening | `eae3409` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_EVENT_TAXONOMY.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | Phase 1 event names and examples now exist in `@bytelyst/events`; broader taxonomy remains open | `41fa2cd`, `76f1b47` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_OWNERSHIP_MATRIX.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | temporary four-party ownership model added | `41fa2cd`, `7a86a76` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_VERIFICATION_MATRIX.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | verification layers exist; repo-level ownership still needs explicit later-phase mapping | `41fa2cd` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_APPROVALS_AND_TRUST_MODEL.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | approval reuse, degraded-device handling, fresh-approval classes, and canonical approval payload requirements are now documented | `eae3409`, `066e75f` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_EVENT_TAXONOMY.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | implemented phase seams plus broader event-family coverage are now documented | `41fa2cd`, `76f1b47`, `617d970` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_OWNERSHIP_MATRIX.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | current four-party model, revision triggers, and next-state ownership shape are now documented | `41fa2cd`, `7a86a76`, `ab50831` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_VERIFICATION_MATRIX.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | repo-level verification ownership and baseline evidence expectations are now documented | `41fa2cd`, `ab50831` | | `ECOSYSTEM_CONTRACT_TEST_STRATEGY.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | executable fixture locations and runtime-route test anchors are now documented | `41fa2cd` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_MARKETPLACE_UNIFICATION.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | draft exists, inventory and entitlement details open | `7a86a76` | -| `ECOSYSTEM_PERSONAL_TIMELINE_PRD.md` | in-progress | `learning_ai_common_plat` | draft exists, hosting and filtering decisions open | `7a86a76` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_MARKETPLACE_UNIFICATION.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | listing schema, entitlement guidance, compatibility, and first inventory mapping are now documented | `7a86a76`, `066e75f` | +| `ECOSYSTEM_PERSONAL_TIMELINE_PRD.md` | done | `learning_ai_common_plat` | timeline hosting choice, noise filtering, and long-term placement guidance are now documented | `7a86a76`, `066e75f` | --- @@ -289,12 +280,12 @@ Example: ## 5. Current Gaps Before Broad Implementation - [x] event taxonomy phase-1 event list hardened in `@bytelyst/events` -- [ ] adoption docs exist for the first flow, but broader repo coverage is still missing -- [ ] ownership model is temporary and must be revised if the team changes -- [ ] verification matrix needs repo-level test ownership +- [x] adoption docs now cover the first flow plus SmartAuth, Auth App, mac-tooling, JarvisJr, Cowork, FlowMonk, ChronoMind, EffoRise, NoteLett, ActionTrail, and MindLyst +- [x] ownership model now documents how it should change if the team expands beyond the current four-party operating model +- [x] verification matrix now includes repo-level test ownership and baseline evidence expectations - [x] contract-test strategy fixture location and validation tooling now exist in `packages/events` -These should be resolved before claiming the ecosystem docs are fully implementation-ready. +These are now resolved for the current documentation baseline. ---